Cornerstone Macro has created a new metric called consumer free cash flow. It shows consumers have a high amount of money to spend on discretionary purchases which is good for the economy. This is in line with the strong consumer sentiment index we will review next. The great part about the consumer free cash flow calculation is we have it laid out in the set of charts below. It is calculated by subtracting the amount of money consumers have after taxes, food, and energy by their cost of debt servicing.
The amount of money consumers have left over after taxes,
food, and energy is overall PCE divided by PCE excluding food and energy.
That’s currently high compared to the past 3 decades. Energy spending as a
percentage of PCE is near a record low. Consumers’ debt servicing is very low
because consumers have deleveraged and interest rates are low. The savings rate
is 7.9% (November). This leads us with the historically and cyclically strong
consumer free cash flow index shown in the bottom chart below.
Improved Consumer Confidence
The Bloomberg Consumer Comfort index has historically been correlated with the Conference Board consumer confidence index. That continued as the first few weeks of the Consumer Comfort indexes have been strong and the latest January consumer confidence index increased. The December consumer confidence index was revised higher by 1.7 points to 128.2. The January reading beat estimates for 127.8 as it came in at 131.6. The present situation index rose from 170.5 to 175.3 and the expectations index increased from 100 to 102.5.
Consumers saying current conditions are good increased from
39% to 40.8%. Those saying conditions are bad fell from 11.1% to 10.4%. As you
can see from the chart above, consumers have become even more confident in the
current job market. Those saying jobs are “plentiful” rose from 46.5% to 49%
and those saying jobs are “hard to get” fell from 13% to 11.6%. The net
difference rose to 37.4%. Consumers’ outlook on the labor market also improved.
The percentage expecting more jobs in the next few months rose from 15.5% to
17.2% and the percentage expecting fewer jobs fell from 13.9% to 13.4%. The net
percentage improved from 1.6% to 3.8%.
Weak Durable Goods Orders
The December durable goods orders report was weak as it
signaled there will be weak business investment growth in Q4. The good news is
the regional Fed manufacturing reports average capex index has improved
(highest since July 2019). That signals business investment growth could
improve in January. Monthly headline durable goods orders growth was 2.4% which
beat estimates for 0.5%. Despite this strong growth rate, this report was weak
because airline orders boosted growth and monthly growth had an easy comp.
November new orders growth was revised down from -2% to -3.1% (comp got
Monthly transportation equipment orders were up 7.6% because defense aircraft orders were up 168.3%. That spike in defense aircraft orders offset the 74.7% decline in civilian aircraft orders. Boeing only received 3 commercial aircraft orders which was down from 63 in November. December is usually a strong month for orders, but the delayed Max 737 made December weak. If the delays end this spring, we will see a boost in headline order growth.
As you can see from the chart above, headline durable goods
orders fell 3.7% yearly. That was up from -4.8%. However, the comp got easier
by 1.7%, so the 2 year growth stack fell 0.6%. The January yearly comp will be
tough, but the rest of the year will have easy comps. Ex-transportation monthly
growth was -0.1% which missed estimates by 3 tenths even though November growth
was only -0.4% (down from 0%).
Core capital goods orders fell 0.9% monthly which missed
estimates for 0.2% and the low end of the estimate range which was 0.1%. The
comp was a very manageable 0.1%. Yearly growth was 0.8%. Yearly non-defense
capital goods orders growth excluding aircraft was 1% which increased from
0.3%. That’s the highest growth since May. The comp got much easier. Last year,
growth fell from 6.1% to 1.9%. Therefore, the 2 year growth stack fell from
6.4% to just 2.9%.
56 ISM PMI?
With the big spike in the Richmond Fed manufacturing index, all 5 regional Fed indexes were up in January. The average of the regional Fed indexes implies the ISM PMI will rise to 56 as you can see from the chart below.
It’s impressive that both the Kansas City and Richmond Fed
indexes increased since they have exposure to Boeing’s supply chain. The
Richmond Fed index and the Philly Fed index drove the regional Fed average
higher. The Richmond index rose from -5 to 20. It more than doubled the highest
estimate which was 9. It beat the consensus of -3, making this the largest beat
since March 2009. The shipments index rose from -6 to 29 and the volume of new
orders index rose 26 points to 13. The backlog of new orders index rose 20
points to 9 and the local business conditions index was up 22 points to 16. The
capex index was up 3 points to 15.
These regional Fed indexes imply the manufacturing recession
is almost over. Remember, if the ISM PMI gets above 50, that’s bad for equity
returns. 6 month expectations in the Richmond Fed report were also strong.
Shipments were up 3 points to 41 and volume of new orders were up 8 points to
37. Local business conditions fell 13 points to 14 and capex was rose 1 point
Consumers have high free cash flow according to Cornerstone
Macro’s calculation. Let’s see if the January retail sales report shows higher
growth. The consumer confidence report agrees with that assessment of the
consumer. On Friday, the December PCE report is expected to show 0.3% month
personal income and consumption growth. The December retail sales report was
decent, but unspectacular. It’s no surprise durable goods orders were weak in
December since there is expected to be weak business investment growth in Q4.
The Q4 GDP report comes out Thursday. The regional Fed reports imply the ISM
PMI will rise to 56, but it has been below what they have expected in recent
Read more awesome articles like this one on VintageValueInvesting.com!