It’s very common for investors to try to figure out if the current long expansion is near its end in which case a recession would start. The chart below is a bit more nuanced because it includes four categories.
In expansions, the economy is either in a boom or a soft patch. In recessions, the economy is either sub-trend or in a deep recession. The results aren’t as clean as we made it sound since sub-trend periods have occurred in and out of official NBER recessions. If the economy is sub-trend in an expansion, it’s very close to being in a recession. If the economy only gets as far as being sub-trend in a recession, the recession was mild.
This is Bank of America’s big data indicator. It’s nifty to notice how nearly all of this expansion has been a soft patch. This explains why the economy can last longer without falling into a recession. There was only a quick boom after the tax cut. This explains why it may have been viable to do a stimulus after the expansion was nine years old. Total growth wasn’t high. It’s notable that the economy is now sub-trend which is the first time that has occurred since the beginning of the last recession. The other two slowdowns didn’t count as sub-trend.
Obviously, this doesn’t mean growth is the weakest of the
cycle. It’s not according to industrial production growth or consumption growth.
It’s also not according to the weekly activity index. The September ECRI coincident
index had 1.8% growth which is still above the trough of about 1% growth in
2016. The soft data is certainly terrible, but it might be too early to justify
the economy being in the sub-trend category.
Global Recession Thought Of As Less Likely
The Bank of America survey below asked fund managers how likely it is that the global economy sees two quarters of negative GDP growth in the next year.
The net percentage had been the highest in years this summer, but managers have recently become slightly more optimistic. Many are projecting an increase in global growth in 2020 because of a boost in emerging markets. The IMF expects growth increasing to 3.4%, while Oxford Economics only sees growth improving from 2.9% to 3.1%. Now would be a great time to make a long bet because the 2020 picture is so uncertain. The problem is there is little evidence of growth rebounding. As support, the bulls only have the global monetary stimulus and India’s corporate tax cut.
Existing Home Sales Fall Slightly
The September existing home sales report had a tough monthly
comp and an easy yearly comp which explains why it had -2.2% monthly growth and
3.9% yearly growth. Yearly growth was the best since March 2017. This was the 3rd
straight month of positive yearly growth. Specifically, sales fell from 5.5
million to 5.38 million as you can see from the chart below. This beat
estimates for 5.44 million. You can look at this report positively or
negatively. On the negative side, year to date sales are down 1.7%. On the positive
side, the 3 month average of sales increased to 0.6% to 5.433 million which is
its 4th straight gain and the highest since May 2018.
The existing housing market needs more inventory to sell more
homes. That’s a big holdup as inventory was 1.83 million units which is down
2.7% from last year. Inventory was 4.1 months in September. That’s up from 4
months in August and down from 4.4 months last year. Home sellers will be
motivated if prices rise. They rose 5.9% to $272,100. That’s the highest yearly
growth since January 2018.
FHFA & MBA Applications
Even though existing home prices spiked, the FHFA home price
index showed yearly price growth in August fell from 5% to 4.6%. The strongest area
was the Mountain region which had 6.5% growth. The weakest were the Pacific and
Middle Atlantic at 3.9% growth. The MBA Mortgage Applications report continued
to show strength as the yearly growth in purchase applications was 6% in the
week of October 18th. That’s down from 12% growth in the prior week.
Below Average Earnings Season
Pick which way you want to look at earnings growth. With the
first 124 S&P 500 firms reporting results, GAAP net income growth is
-10.09%, GAAP EPS growth is -0.46%, non-GAAP net income growth is -2.09%, and
non-GAAP EPS growth is 3.44%. EPS growth is greater than net income growth
because of buybacks.
As you can see from the tables below, this has been a below average quarter.
The average surprise is 3.91% which is below the 3 year average of 4.64%. 66% of firms have beaten sales estimates which is 1% below average. Tech still has 87% of its firms left to report results which is bad news because it has had terrible growth thanks to the global cyclical slowdown. Weakness is being particularly felt by semiconductors.
Democratic Primary Update
As the front runner in the polls in September, Warren experienced more scrutiny. This ended her momentum in the polls. She recently lost 6 points in the latest national poll by the Economist. Biden now leads in the average of polls by 5.4 points. As you can see from the chart below, Warren went from having an over 50% chance of winning to just a 38% chance. She’s still the leader according to the betting market. Mayor Pete has recent gained momentum in the betting market as he’s at 17%. He is emerging as the moderate alternative to Biden. In the latest Iowa poll, he has 20% which is 2nd to Warren at 28% (Biden is at 12%).
The U.S. economy is considered sub-trend by Bank of America,
but it’s probably not weaker than it was in 2016 just yet. The odds of a global
recession according to fund managers recently dropped in the October Bank of
America survey. Existing home sales fell from August, but yearly growth was
positive for the 3rd straight month. Purchase applications are up
and home price growth is falling. Q3 earnings season has been weaker than the 3
year average. Elizabeth Warren lost momentum in the polls, so now she only has a
38% chance of winning the nomination according to the betting market.