We’ve previously discussed how the November ISM manufacturing PMI was weak, while the Markit PMI showed improvement. Even though the Markit PMI hasn’t fallen below 50 this year, it’s not as if the weakness in the ISM reports has been unpredictable. Yearly manufacturing production growth has been negative in 5 of the last 7 months. We will see which November PMI was correct on December 17th which is when the November industrial production report comes out. Either way, the point remains that manufacturing has been in a shallow and wide slowdown in 2H 2019.
According to IIF, this slowdown has occurred because of an inventory overhang. If this thesis is correct, we could see a recovery in the ISM PMI in Q1 2020. As you can see from the chart on the left, the difference between the new orders and inventories index leads the ISM PMI. It bottomed in June 2015 which was ahead of the January 2016 PMI bottom.
In the recent few months, the difference has moved higher as it is positive again. This could lead to an upswing in the PMI. The PMI might join the Markit PMI and the regional Fed reports in positive growth territory. The chart on the right shows, using weight and count, global manufacturing PMIs are rising. This chart uses Markit data which is why it is more optimistic.
Weak ADP Report
The November ADP private sector employment report was weak partially because of small firms. Specifically, the October reading was revised up by 15,000 to 140,000, but the November reading showed 67,000 jobs created which missed estimates for 156,000 and the low end of the estimate range which was 125,000. It would be problematic if the BLS report shows similar results as private sector payrolls are expected to be up 168,000 jobs.
This year, we have paid close attention to very small firms which have shown weakness in hiring growth. It’s not a huge surprise this is occurring because NIPA margins have fallen for 4.5 years. That’s the longest negative stretch since WWII. To be clear, margins haven’t fallen as much as they did in the last recession. Even still, you might expect to see less job creation with lower margins. FactSet shows 2019 S&P 500 EPS growth is expected to be 0.1% and sales growth is expected to be 3.8%. That’s a decline in margins.
Of the 67,000 jobs created in November, 11,000 were from small firms, 29,000 were from midsized firms, and 27,000 were from large firms. The 11,000 jobs added by small firms doesn’t seem terrible, but when you dig deeper, the results were weak in the very small category. Very small firms lost 15,000 jobs and other small firms added 25,000 jobs. As you can see from the chart below, in 5 of the past 7 monthly reports, very small firms have hemorrhaged jobs. This is the weakest period since late 2010 when the economy was just exiting the last recession.
Yearly growth in very small firm employment was 0.1% which was the lowest rate since February 2011. It’s notable that 9,000 of the job losses were in the service sector which has been more consistent in what has been the longest string of job creation by far.
In the overall report, the service sector added 85,000 jobs
and the good providing sector lost 18,000 jobs. Like usual, the education and
healthcare sector led the charge as it added 39,000 jobs. Recently, there was
worry that the leisure and hospitality sector was creating too many jobs as a
percentage of total job creation. This industry doesn’t pay well, but we found no
evidence of it firing people quicker like some claimed. In November, it only
added 18,000 jobs. As a percentage of total job creation, this might be less of
an issue in the BLS report. However, we want to see more job creation in other
industries, not less in leisure and hospitality. The professional and business
industry has been relatively weak in the past few months. It added 28,000 jobs
in November. In Q1 it added an average of 33,786 jobs per month, it added 28,605
per month in Q2, 28,055 in Q3, and so far in Q4 an average of 26,435.
Potentially Solid November Retail Sales Report Coming
It seems like the November retail sales report (which will be released on December 13th) will be strong. Redbook same store sales growth in the week of November 30th was 7.9% which was up from 4.3% in the prior week. That was the strongest growth rate since early January. As we discussed in a previous article, the online sales growth rates on Black Friday and Small Business Saturday were 22.3% and 18%. These sound like great numbers, but keep in mind that online retail almost always takes share from brick and mortar. Even still, the highest growth this cycle was 15.6% in August. These stats on Black Friday and Small Business Saturday are great.
Adding to the positivity, Costco reported great same store
sales growth in November. The firm reported 5.3% same store sales growth which
beat estimates of 4%. That’s even without Cyber Monday being in November. U.S.
comp sales growth was 4.8%. Without gas and forex, same store sales growth was
4.3% which beat estimates for 3.7%. These numbers aren’t just good for Costco;
they signal the consumer was strong in November.
The largest category in the retail sales report is motor vehicle and parts. That’s why the rebound in motor vehicle sales is such a positive indicator. In November sales were 17.1 million which beat estimates for 17 million and rose from 16.5 million. The October report was relatively weak compared to the last few quarters. Domestic vehicle sales improved from 12.7 million to 13.3 million.
We already discussed the weakness in the ISM PMI; however,
we didn’t mention the potential green shoot from the report. The manufacturing
sector appears to be recovering from an inventory overhang. The ADP report
showed some weakness. Leisure and hospitality was a new source of lower growth.
Professional and business has been weak for a few months. Very small firms have
lost jobs for 5 out of the past 7 months. Based on the data from Adobe Analytics,
Redbook, Costco, and the motor vehicle sales report, it seems like the November
retail sales report will be solid.
Read more awesome articles like this one on VintageValueInvesting.com!